GE. 07-14981 (R) 261207 271207 icon

GE. 07-14981 (R) 261207 271207

Смотрите также:

страницы: 1   ...   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
вернуться в начало

Assessment of Implementation of Recommendation 1.4.1

Certain steps to implement the recommendation have begun. On 31 July 2007, the Director General of Police issued Order No. 58/2007 to the effect that civilians taken into police custody shall not be subject to any kind of assaults, and that prison authorities shall treat inmates in a manner that ensures their rights. Similarly, the Director General of NISS issued instructions prohibiting unlawful arrest; detention in places other than designated detention facilities; prohibiting any physical assault or psychological abuse of prisoners; and safeguarding the dignity of individuals during arrest. The term “assault” in both instructions can be interpreted to encompass torture and summary executions. While these also related to arbitrary detention and forced disappearances, Police Order No. 58/2007 did not deal specifically with these human rights violations. Furthermore, the two orders mentioned above did not apply to the armed forces or any militias under the Government’s control.

According to the information received, cases of arbitrary detention, torture and summary executions continued.

Recommendation 1.4.2 Short term

Refrain from detaining anyone incommunicado. Close all unofficial places of detention. Ensure that all persons, including any civilians held by Military Intelligence and National Security are promptly brought before a judicial arrest following arrest and regularly thereafter. Ensure that accessible, complete, accurate and fully up to date lists of detainees are kept, and shared with families of the detainees. Refrain from detaining civilians in military installations.

Indicators: No instances of secret or incommunicado detention reported. Up to date lists of detainees available.

Response of the Government of the Sudan on Recommendation 1.4.2

Written information submitted to the group of experts on Darfur on 21 August 2007

The Department of Public Prosecutions received 33 suspects and after making preliminary inquiries charged 8 of them, pursuant to criminal indictment sheet No. 138/2007, under the following articles of the Criminal Code of 1991: articles 21 (association), 24 (criminal conspiracy), 25 (incitement), 26 (aiding and abetting), 50 (violating the Constitution), 51 (incitement of war against the State), 57 (entering and photographing military sites), 58 (incitement to sedition) and 60 (using military uniforms and symbols), articles 18 and 26 of the Weapons and Ammunition Act and articles 5 and 6 of the Counter Terrorism Act. The Minister confirmed that the accused were receiving excellent treatment.

^ Information orally submitted to the group of experts on 18 September 2007

Regarding unofficial places of detention the Government replied that the Constitution of 1998 prohibited detention outside official places of detention unless these were established under the National Security Law. The Guidance of the Director General of the National Intelligence and Security Service and of 12 August 2007 was not issued in response to an existing situation and no illegal places of detention needed to be closed. The security services have their official places of detention, supervised by the Prosecutor.

With regard to reports of ‘ghost house’s’, an investigation into the issue showed that some militias with whom Sudan signed peace agreements had illegal places of detention in Khartoum. The Government identified these places and closed them down. Last week, reacting to information about weapon cashes, the police raided the place. Reports that official authorities had secret places of detention have not been confirmed. Currently there are therefore no unofficial places of detention in Sudan under the authority of NISS.

^ Written information submitted to the group of experts on Darfur on 30 October 2007

The Government submitted to the group of experts on Darfur a list of detainees in Darfur which indicates that there were 70 detainees between 1 June and 30 October 2007, in particular, 41 in South Darfur and 29 in West Darfur. The Government stated that most detainees were released and remained in detention for periods between 10 days to two months. Seven detainees were referred to the Attorney General and one to the Police. Ten detainees remained in detention when the document was submitted to the group of experts.


Information Received from Other Sources on Recommendation 1.4.2

The Group received many reports of secret or incommunicado detention during recent months. See some illustrative examples which have been recounted above under ‘Information Received from Other Sources on Recommendation 1.4.1’, in particular those incidents of incommunicado detention reported to have occurred in South Darfur.


Assessment of Implementation of Recommendation 1.4.2

Implementation seems to have begun, but because reports of incommunicado detention continue to be received, it appears that improvements have yet to be felt on the ground. No information was provided with regard to closure of all unofficial places of detention. There were reports that many civilians held by Military Intelligence and National Security were not brought promptly before the judiciary following arrest. A list of detainees was provided by the Government. However, no documents were provided with regard to whether information was shared with families of the detainees. Also no information was provided whether civilians were detained in military installations or elsewhere. There seemed to be persistent ambiguity over persons detained under national security laws and the extent to which places of detention were known outside the NISS. Information provided by the Government did not indicate precisely the place of detention, only the state, for example, ‘South Darfur’ or ‘West Darfur’.

Recommendation 1.4.3 Short term

Issue and enforce clear instructions that detainees must be provided all guarantees provided for under international law to ensure they are being lawfully detained and have access to fair trial. This includes notification of reasons for arrest upon arrest, immediate access to a lawyer upon arrest, access to family members, and being presently promptly before a judicial authority.

Indicators: Instructions issued and widely disseminated. Number of incidents of denial of such guarantees.

оставить комментарий
Размер0,84 Mb.
ТипДокументы, Образовательные материалы
Добавить документ в свой блог или на сайт

страницы: 1   ...   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12
Ваша оценка этого документа будет первой.
Ваша оценка:
Разместите кнопку на своём сайте или блоге:

База данных защищена авторским правом ©exdat 2000-2017
При копировании материала укажите ссылку
обратиться к администрации
Курсовые работы